If you choose “approved by” and “approval comments” in the view fields option, that will should give you what you are looking for. I also always add the ID, Title, and approved date to make sure that I am seeing the right thing.   

You can also double check you have repeating sections on the report.  If you add the field to a repeating section then this will show all approvers.  

You can find more details at Adding repeating sections to reports

Hi,

I have a similar report to show each draft approvers response and date as well as the document approval cycle status i.e. Submitted, Stopped, Complete. I have attached a file showing the report designer configuration.

Hopefully this helps.

Best Regards,

Steven

​@Steven Crossan is absolutely correct.  This report shows the “bands” you need to add.  Current Approval Cycle will show information related to the cycle (status, when it was submitted, etc) and then the Approval Items band will show users, their response, etc.

Thanks for sharing Steve!